Starch-Based Diets No Answer for Diabetics
While they are a step in the right direction, grain- and
starch-based diets pose risks for diabetics.
By Joel Fuhrman, M.D.
Iwant to make it clear that diabetics can’t just “eat better.”
They have to go all the way and follow the vegetable-based
diet I
call Eat To Live (ETL). This is the only dietary approach
that lowers cholesterol, improves the cholesterol ratio,
and lowers triglycerides.
With only one or two exceptions, other vegetarian
diets simply are not as effective or safe because they typically
rely heavily on cooked starchy vegetables, such as bread,grains,and
potatoes. The recommendations of vegetarian diet authors,such
as Dean
Ornish and John McDougall, can be helpful for the general
public but are far from ideal for those with diabetes. Certain
individuals may experience beneficial changes after adopting
recommendations such as these, since they are a big improvement
over the Standard American Diet (SAD), but most diabetics
will not achieve the results available to them unless they
adopt the ETL approach.
Diabetics need to avoid baked starchy vegetables
and flour-based products. Most low-fat and vegetarian- type
diets are cooked starch- and grain-based, not steamed vegetable based.
By utilizing more green vegetables, beans, nuts, and even
fruit,
the ETL approach sets the stage for more dramatic weight
loss and more effective glucose lowering.
The ETL vegetable-based dietary program
is the only dietary intervention ever shown in medical studies
to lower cholesterol more effectively than cholesterol-lowering
medication. Other styles of plant-based dietary interventions—
because they are grain- and potato based— have been relatively
ineffective
at lowering cholesterol. Although the low-fat vegetarian
diet lowered LDL cholesterol 16 percent, it raised triglycerides
18.7
percent, and the LDL/HDL ratio remained unchanged, reflecting
minimal overall improvement.
The ETL approach differed in that the LDL
cholesterol was more
significantly lowered (33 percent) without unfavorable impact
on
HDL or triglycerides, reflecting sizable improvement in
reducing
the risk of heart attack. ETL simply is the most cardio-protective
dietary approach one can follow, which is of crucial importance
since diabetics have such an increased cardiac risk.
Exposure to advanced glycation end products
Another reason why typical vegetarian diets are not ideal
for diabetics is they are not designed to avoid exposure
to advanced glycation end products (AGEs). There is a huge
body of literature documenting that the high sugar in the
bloodstream
in diabetics promotes the formation of AGEs in the body
as
the sugars react with body proteins. The formation of advanced
glycation end products (AGEs) on connective tissue and within
cells stiffens and ages your blood vessels and accelerates
aging throughout the body. AGEs are a significant causal
factor of the horrible side effects of diabetes, such as
blindness, kidney failure, heart attacks, and strokes.The
chemical modifications
of cells that occur as a result of the accumulation of AGEs
are
one of the primary hallmarks of aged and diseased tissues.
But the accumulation of AGEs in the body
does not result solely from increased sugar in the bloodstream.
AGEs also are formed when starchy foods are cooked at higher
temperatures, causing molecular rearrangement. Acrylamides
are an example of AGEs that occur from cooking carbohydrates—such
as potatoes and grains—in the absence of water. The higher
the temperature, the
more these toxic compounds are formed. Neither acrylamides
nor other AGEs are formed when vegetables are steamed or
cooked in soups.
Refined carbohydrates in bakery products
and processed foods can cause heart attacks even in people
who are not diabetic,1 but these products are even more
dangerous for diabetics, since diabetics are more sensitive
to the damaging effects of AGEs. Vegetarians (my wife calls
them “vegjunktarians”) who eat large quantities of cooked
starches and honey were found to have higher measurable
levels of AGEs than people eating a more
omnivorous diet.2 To be lifespan promoting and diabetic-eversing,
vegetarian diets must be designed to minimize exposure to
large amounts of cooked starches and simple sugars. In addition,
they must be very high in fiber to maximize
glucose lowering. My high nutrient ETL approach meets all
of
these criteria.
Dr. Fuhrman’s Diabetic Reversal Menu
Enjoy this one-day sample menu of delicious, easy-to-prepare,
healthful meals.
Soaked Oatmeal Supreme
1/3 cup raw oat flakes
1 Tbsp. flaxseed
6 walnut halves, crushed
1 pint fresh or frozen strawberries, sliced in half
Put the oat flakes in a cup, fill the cup with water, and
place it in the refrigerator.
In the morning, the oat flakes will be softened. Cut in
the fruit, mix in the flaxseed, and sprinkle the crushed
walnut on top.
Blood Orange Dressing
1 navel orange, peeled
2 Tbsp. blood orange vinegar
6 raw, unsalted cashew nuts
Place peeled orange,vinegar, and nuts in blender and blend
until smooth. Serve with a large green salad.
Tomato-Bean Soup
6 tomatoes
1 cup mushrooms, chopped
2 leeks, washed and chopped
1 onion, chopped
1/2 cup adzuki beans
3 cups bok choy, chopped
2 Tbsp. VegeBase
1 tsp. Mrs. Dash seasoning
3 cups water
Place ingredients in a pot;cover and simmer for two hours
on a low flame.Purée the tomatoes,onions,and leeks,and then
stir back in with the other ingredients. Leave all other
ingredients in small chunks. Serves two.
Scallion-Eggplant Dip
1 eggplant
3 scallions, chopped
3 garlic cloves, minced
1/2 tsp. mixed Italian herbs
Bake the eggplant until soft.After it has cooled, scoop
out the soft inner flesh and blend it with the remaining
ingredients. Serve with raw vegetables.
Garlicky Spinach
1 large (16 oz.) bag of frozen
spinach (defrosted)
4 garlic cloves, chopped
1 cup oil-free tomato sauce
Mix the spinach and chopped garlic into a pot with the oil-free
tomato sauce. Simmer on a low flame for 15 minutes, stirring
occasionally. Serves two.
Zucchini & Mushrooms
2-4 zucchini
1 cup mushrooms
1/2 tsp. onion powder
1/2 lemon, juiced
1 Tbsp. lightly toasted sesame seeds
Steam the zucchini and mushrooms just until they are soft.
Sprinkle with onion powder, lemon juice, and sesame seeds.
Tofu-Bean Chili
1 cup unsalted canned kidney
beans
4 oz. tomato paste
1 cup red onion, chopped fine
2 cups firm tofu
1 tsp. chili powder
1 Tbsp. Riesling raisin vinegar
1 cup plum tomatoes, chopped
1/2 cup green or red peppers, chopped
Cut the tofu into thin strips and then bake on a wire rack
in the oven at 275º for 30 minutes to harden.Chop the tofu
into small chunks and mix with the remaining ingredients.
MENU
Breakfast
Grapefruit
Soaked Oatmeal Supreme
Lunch
Large Green Salad with
Blood Orange Dressing
Tomato-Bean Soup
Dinner
Raw Veggies with
Scallion-Eggplant Dip
Garlicky Spinach
Zucchini & Mushrooms
Tofu-Bean Chili
Dessert/Snack
Two Kiwifruits